Although Shay is delighted to find herself back in Lucas' arms, she can't get Jonathan out of her mind. She tells herself that she just feels guilty for hurting him, but could it be something more? Lucas' trust issues still cause him to keep her at a distance, and she is not sure if she can ever earn his trust after sleeping with Jonathan. She begins to doubt that she has made the right choice in rejecting Jonathan, but her heart tells her she could choose no differently.
But Jonathan isn't ready to let Shay go so easily, and he is determined to hurt Lucas by stealing her away. How far will he go to claim Shay as his own?